April 26, 2025

Tyler Robenolt

Tyler Robenolt
Follow Tyler Robenolt

Get notified by email when this case is updated.

Name:
Robenolt, Tyler Austin

Date of Booking:
04/23/2025

Reason(s) For Booking:
BATTERY-MISD.

Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]

[NARRATIVE #1 on April 04, 2025]

On 04/04/2025 at approximately 2333 hours, I responded to the rear of Ned Kelly’s, 119 South Wayne Street, in reference to a subject bleeding. When I arrived on scene, I saw victim, Dalton Smith, bleeding from the head and off duty firefighter, [REDACTED] rendering aid. As I approached the subjects, [REDACTED] stated when he walked outside, he saw Smith on the ground bleeding. [REDACTED] stated after speaking with Smith, he was told that Smith was “jumped” by a couple of unknown males.

I then asked Smith if he could describe them so I could put the description out on the radio to other officers in the area. Smith stated they were white males wearing cargo shorts and collared shirts. Smith was visibly intoxicated and still worked up/shaken from the incident. EMS arrived on scene and began treating Smith.

Due to Smith still being worked up, I waited until he got to the hospital to continue questioning Smith about what happened so he would be calm.

When I arrived at the hospital, I photographed Smith’s injuries. Smith had several lacerations to his head, back, and a mark on his throat.

I then asked Smith, now calm, what happened. Smith stated when he walked out of Ned Kelly’s he heard a guy say, “hey buddy come over here.” Smith stated when he walked over to the male, someone came up behind him and choked him. Smith stated another male, that was in front of him hit him approximately four times. Smith stated he was “messed up” at that point and that was the best he could remember.

I then called the owner of Ned Kelly’s, [WITNESS #1], and requested video of the incident. [WITNESS #1] stated he was out of town but would contact someone to help him pull the video for me. No video was available by the end of shift.

[End of Narrative]

[NARRATIVE #2 on April 04, 2025]

On 04/04/2025 at approximately 2300 hours, I was dispatched to Century Bank Parking lot, 119 South Wayne Street, where I contacted witness, [WITNESS #2], in reference to an assault that occurred at the location.

[WITNESS #2] advised she was inside Ned Kelly’s Down Under, 119 South Wayne Street, and was exiting the bar through the back door. [WITNESS #2] stated as she approached the back door, she observed a male, Dalton Smith, laying on the ground with four unknown men surrounding him attacking him. [WITNESS #2] stated she could not give an exact description of the males other than that they were wearing collard shirts and khakis.

[End of Narrative]

[NARRATIVE #3 on April 06, 2025]

On 04/06/2025 at approximately 0042 hours, I responded to the front door of Ned Kelly’s in reference to one of the bouncers recognizing one of the males from this fight returning.

When I arrived on scene, spoke with a bouncer who stated one of the males involved in the fight from the previous night was currently inside of Ned Kelly’s. The bouncer stated he and another bouncer “[WITNESS #3]” broke up the fight. I then had the bouncer go find the subject and bring him outside. The bouncer then went inside of the club and walked back out with a male, later identified by his Georgia Driver’s License as Benjamin Hise. When I first saw Hise I noticed a mark/bruise on the left side of his face. When asked, Hise admitted he was involved in the fight behind Ned Kelly’s the previous night. Hise stated he and a couple of his friends were sitting at the picnic table in the back-parking lot. Hise stated they noticed Smith and asked him if he was okay. Hise stated Smith did not respond and continued to walk around and talk to himself. Hise stated he asked Smith to sit down with them when Smith asked Hise if they were laughing at him. Hise stated Smith then walked up behind one of his friends, later identified as Tyler Robenolt, and put him in a choke hold causing him to temporally go unconscious. Hise stated he then got Smith off of Robenolt and put Smith in a choke hold until Smith went limp. Hise stated he then let Smith up and allowed Smith to walk away. Hise stated Smith then picks up a brick. Hise stated he went to get his friend who drove them to leave when Smith his him in the face with the brick. Hise stated he then punches and choked Smith out. Hise stated he did not know what else to do because Smith has already choked his friend out and hit him with a brick.

When asked, Hise stated another one of his friends that were involved was currently inside of Ned Kelly’s. Hise then momentarily walked off and came back with Robenolt. When asked, Robenolt stated he along with Hise and another female were on the bench behind Ned Kelly’s when Smith came up to them stumbling. Robenolt stated he could tell Smith was having a bad time and asked him to come sit down with them. Robenolt stated Smith appeared to of thought about it but backed off. Robenolt stated Smith then put him in a choke hold causing him to go unconscious for several seconds. Robenolt stated when he regained consciousness, he saw Hise and Smith on the ground. Robenolt stated they then went back inside of Ned Kelly’s.

After speaking with Robenolt, I began getting a clothing description of what they were wearing for when I do see the video. Hise stated he was wearing a blue shirt, khaki pants, and flip flops. Robenolt stated he was wearing a long gray Eagles shirt, black shorts, a black bandanna, and white shoes.

I told Hise and Robenolt that I was not looking to pursue charges at that time due to having drastically different statements. I told them I wanted to review video footage before making any decisions, but I would be in contact with them after I watch the video.

After speaking with Hise and Robenolt, I briefly spoke with the bouncer who stated he did not see what happened, but he did see males fleeing from the area and a male, Smith, on the ground. The bouncer stated they do not have access to the cameras, but they have been in contact with [WITNESS #1] and told him the times to get the video.

I then reached out to [WITNESS #1] again to check on the status of the video. [WITNESS #1] stated he has not been able to get in touch with “[REDACTED]” to get the video, but he would get back with me.

No video has been obtained by the end of shift. A photograph was taken of the injury on the side of Hise’s face.

[End of Narrative]

[NARRATIVE #4 on April 16, 2025]

On 04/16/2025 at approximately 2140 hours, I met with the owner of Ned Kelly’s, [WITNESS #1], to retrieve video from this incident.

When I reviewed the video, I saw at 2245 hours (video time) Benjamin Hise and Tyler Robenolt sitting at the picnic table behind Ned Kelly’s and Dalton Smith (appearing highly intoxicated) was standing behind them appearing to have a disagreement with his girlfriend. The video does have sound; however, they were not talking loud enough for me to hear them at this point. I then see Smith’s girlfriend walk off. As Smith’s girlfriend walks off, Smith leaned over the picnic table as if he was going to engage with Hise and Robenolt’s conversation. I then see Smith wrap his arm around Robenolt’s neck from behind and pull him off the bench of the picnic table by his neck, unknown what was said because they were still not talking loud enough for the camera. As Smith was pulling Robenolt by his neck, I could then hear Hise say “hey hey” as he runs over behind Smith and puts him in a choke hold momentarily to get him to release Robenolt.

I then see Smith and Robenolt go to the ground where Hise begins punching Smith several times to get him to let go of Robenolt. When Smith let Robenolt go, I saw Hise put Smith in a choke hold and call him a “bi*ch a*s boy” and “don’t do that sh*t.” Hise then looks towards the parking lot, in the direction Smith’s girlfriend walked towards, out of camera frame, and stated, “come get him.” Though Smith’s girlfriend did not come back into camera frame, Hise let Smith go. Hise then stood up and told Smith to get up and walk away. Hise then picked Smith up off the ground and told him again to walk away. As Smith was walking off, Hise took a couple of steps towards him when I saw Smith’s girlfriend come back into frame. As Smith’s girlfriend was walking off with Smith, Hise stated “he’s going to be hurting tomorrow.” Smith and his girlfriend then walk out of camera frame.

At approximately 2310 hours, (video time) Smith was seen coming back into camera frame and Hise and Robenolt were back sitting at the picnic table. As Smith approached near the back door of Ned Kelly’s, he was walking towards Hise and Robenolt and cannot be heard saying anything to them. When Hise sees Smith walking up, Hise says “hey bro, come here” as he stands up from the picnic table. Smith then continues to walk in the direction he was already going and did not approach them. Hise and Robenolt then jog up to Smith to stop him. I then see Hise grab Smith from behind and hold him so he could not protect himself while Robenolt punches him in the face. After Smith was punched in the face, Hise let him go and they appear to have a conversation, but I cannot hear what was said.

Smith is then seen walking to an area where debris was laying from recent construction as Hise and Robenolt walk back towards the picnic table. Smith was then seen picking up an object, possibly a large rock or a brick and wipe the dirt off it. Smith then tosses it from one hand to the other as if he was testing the weight of it. Hise and Robenolt were then seen walking back into Ned Kelly’s. As Hise and Robenolt are walking back inside of Ned Kelly’s, Smith begins walking towards the picnic tables while still holding said rock/brick. Once Smith approaches the picnic tables, he hides the object behind his back until he gets to the opposite end of the picnic table. Once at the end of the picnic table, he sets the object on the table and sits on said table, right outside the back door of Ned Kelly’s.

At 2314 hours (video time) Hise and Robenolt were seen exiting out of the back door of Ned Kelly’s. Smith then picks up the brick and swings it at the side of Hise’s head. Hise then grabs Smith in an attempt to protect himself. Smith was then pulled to the ground where Hise began punching him. While Hise was punching Smith, Robenolt was seen kicking/stomping Smith. An unknown female is also seen hitting and kicking Smith. While this is occurring, an unknown male approaching the back door of Ned Kelly’s began yelling at them as if he was trying to get them to stop. Robenolt then tells the male “he choked me out earlier.” Robenolt then turns around and stomps on Smith again and told him to “stay down pu*sy.” Once again, Robenolt was seen stomping on Smith 2-3 more times before the unknown male yells at them to stop again.

Once Smith was back on his feet, Robenolt was seen walking around behind Smith and kick him in the back. At this time, male subjects in orange shirts, suspected bouncers from Ned Kelly’s came outside. I then hear Hise tell them “he tried to hit me with a brick.” Hise and Robenolt then began walking off while still taunting Smith.

After reviewing the video, I secured warrants on Smith for aggravated assault X2. Warrants were also secured for Hise and Robenolt for battery.

[End of Narrative]

Premium feature
Keep scrolling, keep reading
Premium members never stop here - as they scroll, the next story in Baldwin County loads right below this one, post after post, all on one page and completely ad-free. Sign up and read the news the easy way.
Get Premium