Get notified by email when this case is updated.
The Georgia Gazette is actively monitoring this case. Check back for the latest updates as more information becomes available.
Name:
Alsup, Alicia Kelly-Anne
Date of Booking:
05/26/2025
Reason(s) For Booking:
Aggravated Cruelty to Animals
Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]
On Monday, May 26, 2025, at approximately 1550 Hours, I was notified by Corporal Anders, Bartow County Sheriff’s Office Officer #915, that she was currently at [100 BLOCK] Old Tennessee Rd, Cartersville, Georgia 30121, regarding Suspicious activity involving a U-haul truck and several animals that were deceased or in distress. Corporal Anders advised that she had seen several animals that were in distress or deceased. I advised her to have Bartow Dispatch call the on-call animal control officer so they could be en route.
At approximately 1642 hours, Officer Gibson with Bartow County Animal Control notified me and advised that he would need my assistance. He confirmed that several animals were deceased and many more needed emergency assistance. Officer Gibson also informed me that, due to the large number of animals, he would require additional animal control trucks on the scene to collect the animals.
Upon my arrival at 1758 hours, I observed that the property itself was in complete disarray. I saw trash and debris scattered throughout the property. I observed several dogs running freely throughout the property. Many of the animals running at large appeared to be underweight and had poor hair coats. Poor skin coat conditions usually indicate poor diet and unsanitary conditions. I then located Animal Control Officer Gibson and observed that he was working to unload animals from a large U-Haul box truck. As I approached the car, I could smell a strong, pungent odor that was emanating from the U-haul truck. As I approached the rear of the vehicle, the conditions were unbearable.
I observed several deceased animals located inside crates that were placed inside the U-haul truck. The truck itself was a large box truck and had absolutely no ventilation. The back of the truck had approximately 3 to 4 inches of water in it, where it appears that animals were either being sprayed off to cool down or it was being sprayed to attempt to clean. However, if it was for cleaning, it was not being adequately performed, as the cages were covered in feces, urine, and wastewater. Due to the lack of drainage, U-Haul trucks are not designed for transporting animals. Inside the U-haul truck, six large, various-breed dogs were deceased.
I then relocated to the back of the property, where another twenty-plus dogs were located inside dog kennels. The kennels were approximately 10 feet by 10 feet in size and had entry gates. There were six kennels connected, giving an L-shaped design. The first three kennels had dogs inside them. Many of the animals in the kennels were suffering and in distress. Some of the animals in the kennel were already deceased, and others were barely holding on. There were a few that were able to walk around, but given their age, they were not as spunky as they should have been for their age group. The animals that were barely holding on appeared lethargic, and a quick inspection of their gums suggested they were anemic. Several animals had loose, runny stools that also contained blood; they were lying in it because they lacked the strength to move themselves out of it.
The smell inside the kennels was horrific; it was an iron-like odor, likely due to the large amount of blood present in the animals’ stools. It also smelled of death. The animals inside the kennel that were deceased were exhibiting signs of rigor mortis and had a large number of flies attacking their bodies. The kennels were also covered in feces and had an ammonia-like smell, indicating the presence of high levels of urine. The kennels were unsanitary and unfit for animals to live in. Most of the animals that were living were exhibiting signs of disease and other medical conditions. The animals were confiscated and placed into the custody of the Bartow County Animal Control.
After collecting all the dogs from outside the property, property Owner [WITNESS #1], allowed and consented to our entry into the residence to check the welfare of the animals inside. Due to the exigent circumstances: unsanitary conditions, deceased dogs, and the other animals in extremely fragile states, it was pertinent to check the welfare of the other animals on the inside of the property. Mr. [WITNESS #1] was very helpful and allowed us inside the residence, telling us the animals were located in the bedroom beside the living room on the left. Once inside, I opened the door to the bedroom.
I observed five dogs inside the bedroom. They were in somewhat better living conditions than those on the outside, but still not in ideal situations. The floor in the bedroom was covered in feces, urine, and blood. The animals were walking through the waste matter and also lying on bedding that was saturated with feces and urine. The animals inside the home were also taken due to their poor living conditions and concerns about their welfare and safety.
Together, a total of 46 dogs were removed from the property on May 26, 2025, and 1 dog on May 27, 2025, for a total of 47 dogs. Of that, 10 animals were deceased. The animals were taken to the Bartow County Animal Shelter, where Shelter veterinarian [REDACTED] was present to examine all the animals. During transport to the shelter, another four animals passed away due to the poor conditions. The veterinarian determined that another 16 dogs were in too poor a condition to be treated and were humanely euthanized. Altogether, 16 were euthanized by the veterinarian, 14 were deceased either on the property or en route to the shelter, and 18 have been quarantined and are being monitored due to fear of being diseased.
I then debriefed with Corporal Anders, and based on her findings through testimonial evidence and my own findings through the physical evidence established on scene, the main caretakers/owners of the dogs (Alicia Alsup and Tucker Campbell) were placed under arrest for aggravated animal cruelty to animals (X3).
Through Corporal Ander’s investigation, it was determined by testimonial evidence that both Alicia and Tucker were using the U-Haul truck to transport the animals in an attempt to rehome them. Alicia stated that they traveled up to two hours away out of state with the animals in crates inside the un-airconditioned, unventilated U-Haul truck. While the ambient temperatures outside were in the mid-to-upper 80s, the humidity for the day was also in the 90s. She stated they would give them breaks every so often. However, being inside an enclosed vehicle with no air or ventilation put the dogs in severe distress. It ultimately resulted in the untimely death of those in the U-Haul truck.
Along with Alicia and Tucker, several friends assisted in either loading the animals into the U-haul truck or assisting in the neglect of the dogs. Based on the testimonial evidence, it appeared that Gabriel Cammon, Garland Adams, and Cody Reimer had all actively participated in the neglect/death of the animals involved. Gabriel, Garland, and Cody were placed under arrest for aggravated animal cruelty to animals (X1).
Alicia, Tucker, and Cody all bore witness to the weather conditions. She continued to allow the dogs to be transported in the harsh environment without providing the basic care and preventive measures that a reasonable person would have taken in a similar situation.
Alicia, Tucker, Cody, Gabriel, and Garland were later transported to the Bartow County Jail without incident. I later secured warrants on all of these individuals.
[End of Narrative]
Article:
47 dogs removed from Bartow property, 6 found dead inside U-Haul truck — Bartow County News
All information is sourced directly from the official, public court database. Case history is organized and curated by The Georgia Gazette staff. The “What this means:” explanations are written by AI and reviewed by our staff before publishing.
Court records are subject to change at the court’s discretion. The Georgia Gazette is not responsible for errors or omissions. Nothing here is legal advice. All individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
Case History:
5/19/25
MOTION FOR BOND FILED
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s attorney filed a motion requesting that she be allowed to post bond for release from custody. This motion would have been filed after her initial arrest on the booking date of 5/25/25.
6/3/25
BOND SET AT $15,000 AND POSTED 6/4/25
What this means: The court set Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s initial bond at $15,000, and she posted that bond the following day to secure her release from custody while awaiting further court proceedings.
8/7/25
RETURN NOTICE FOR MOTION TO REVOKE BOND HEARING SCHEDULED 8/12/25 AT 9:00 AM
What this means: A court hearing was scheduled for 8/12/25 to address the state’s motion to revoke Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s bond in Bartow County.
8/9/25
MOTION TO REVOKE BOND FILED
What this means: The prosecution filed a motion asking the court to revoke Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s bond, which would have required her to return to jail. This suggests the state believed she had violated conditions of her release or committed new offenses.
8/13/25
ORDER REVOKING BOND
What this means: A judge ordered that Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s bond be revoked, meaning she could no longer remain free while awaiting trial and would have to return to jail. This typically happens when a defendant violates conditions of their bond or commits new offenses.
8/21/25
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY STEWART BRATCHER
What this means: Attorney Stewart Bratcher filed paperwork to formally represent Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup in her case in Bartow County.
9/3/25
CONSOLIDATED MOTION FILED
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s defense team filed a consolidated motion, which combines multiple legal requests into one filing. The specific requests in this motion are not detailed in the case updates.
9/3/25
SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL TO RANDALL IVEY
What this means: The court approved a change in Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s legal representation, with attorney Randall Ivey replacing her previous attorney in the Bartow County case.
9/17/25
MOTION TO REINSTATE BOND FILED
What this means: Following the revocation of her bond on 8/13/25, Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s attorney filed a motion asking the court to reinstate her bond so she could be released from custody again.
10/9/25
INDICTMENT FILED WITH 87 COUNTS OF AGGRAVATED CRUELTY TO ANIMALS AND 22 COUNTS OF CRUELTY TO ANIMALS
What this means: A grand jury in Bartow County formally charged Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup with 109 total animal cruelty charges – 87 counts of aggravated cruelty to animals (the more serious charge) and 22 counts of cruelty to animals. An indictment means the grand jury found probable cause that she committed these alleged crimes.
10/14/25
ORDER SETTING BOND AMOUNT AT $15,000
What this means: The court set Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s bond at $15,000 following her indictment. This gave her the opportunity to post bail and be released from custody while her case proceeds through the court system.
10/20/25
WAIVER OF ARRAIGNMENT BY DEFENDANT THROUGH ATTORNEY RANDALL IVEY
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup, represented by attorney Randall Ivey, waived her right to appear in court for arraignment. By waiving arraignment, she formally acknowledged the charges against her without having to appear before the judge to enter a plea.
10/24/25
BOND POSTED
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup posted her $15,000 bond and was released from custody in Bartow County. She can remain free while her case proceeds but must follow any conditions set by the court.
1/12/26
CALENDAR CALL SCHEDULED AT 9:00 AM
What this means: A calendar call was scheduled for Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case, where the court reviews the status of pending cases and schedules future hearings or trial dates.
1/14/26
STATE DISCLOSURE CERTIFICATE AND NOTICES – STATE’S DISCOVERY
What this means: The prosecution in Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case filed required disclosure documents and discovery materials with the Bartow County court, providing the defense with evidence and information the state plans to use at trial.
1/28/26
DEFENSE MOTION TO WITHDRAW – MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s attorney filed a motion asking the court for permission to withdraw from representing her in the Bartow County case. Attorneys must get court approval to stop representing a defendant in an ongoing criminal case.
2/10/26
ORDER TO WITHDRAW GRANTED
What this means: The court approved the motion allowing Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s attorney to withdraw from representing her in the Bartow County case, leaving her without legal representation.
2/10/26
CALENDAR CALL SCHEDULED AT 9:00 AM
What this means: Another calendar call was scheduled for Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case to review the status and schedule future proceedings, likely taking into account her change in legal representation.
2/17/26
ENTRY OF APPEARANCE BY ATTORNEY STEWART BRATCHER
What this means: Attorney Stewart Bratcher filed paperwork to represent Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup again in her Bartow County case, taking over after her previous attorney was allowed to withdraw.
2/17/26
MOTION TO WITHDRAW – PRELIMINARY MOTION TO SUPPRESS
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s new attorney Stewart Bratcher filed a motion asking to withdraw a previously filed preliminary motion to suppress evidence in her case.
2/17/26
MOTION FOR DISCOVERY – DEMAND FOR DISCOVERY
What this means: Attorney Stewart Bratcher filed a motion demanding that the prosecution provide all discoverable evidence in Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case, including witness statements, physical evidence, and other materials required to be shared with the defense.
3/31/26
STATUS HEARING SCHEDULED
What this means: A status hearing was scheduled for Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case in Bartow County, where the court will review the current state of proceedings and address any pending motions or scheduling matters.
4/10/26
DEFENSE MOTION FOR COMPETENCY EVALUATION FILED
What this means: Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s defense attorney, Stewart Bratcher, filed a motion requesting that the court order a competency evaluation. This motion asks the court to determine whether Alsup is mentally fit to stand trial — that is, whether she understands the charges against her and can assist in her own defense. The court will need to rule on this motion.
4/14/26
CALENDAR CALL HEARING SCHEDULED AT 9:00 AM
What this means: Another calendar call hearing was scheduled for Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case in Bartow County, where the court will review the current status of her animal cruelty case and address any pending motions or schedule future proceedings.
4/15/26
PROPOSED ORDER FOR MENTAL EVALUATION SUBMITTED
What this means: The court received a proposed order for a mental evaluation of Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup. This is a draft document prepared by one of the parties (likely the defense) that outlines the terms under which the evaluation would take place.
4/23/26
ORDER FOR MENTAL EVALUATION ISSUED
What this means: The Bartow County court issued an order requiring Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup to undergo a mental evaluation. This evaluation will help determine her competency to stand trial in the aggravated cruelty to animal’s case.
6/2/26
CALENDAR CALL SCHEDULED AT 9:00 AM
What this means: A calendar call was scheduled for Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case in Bartow County, where the court will review the status of her animal cruelty charges and address any pending matters or schedule future proceedings.
8/18/26
CALENDAR CALL SCHEDULED
What this means: A calendar call has been scheduled for Alicia Kelly-Anne Alsup’s case in Bartow County on August 18, 2026, at 9:00 a.m. A calendar call is a brief court appearance where the judge and attorneys confirm that the case is ready to proceed and discuss the next steps. This typically occurs after a competency evaluation has been completed.