Get notified by email when this case is updated.
Name:
McGill, Timothy Wayne
Date of Booking:
06/27/2025
Reason(s) For Booking:
DISORDERLY CONDUCT
Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]
On June 28, 2025, I was requested to return to [300 BLOCK] Shearouse Rd in reference to a previous call for service involving Timothy McGill. Mr. McGill contacted 911 and claimed that a man named [WITNESS #1] a friend of his wife [REDACTED], had threatened him. He alleged that [WITNESS #1] said he was going to come over and “put a stop to him terrorizing [REDACTED],” though the threat was made using vague language.
I first spoke with Mr. McGill over the phone. He requested that I call [REDACTED] and instruct her, [WITNESS #1], and any other associates to stop threatening him. I advised Mr. McGill that I would require specific evidence or statements to justify contacting third parties. At that point, Mr. McGill became argumentative, disorderly, and verbally insulting-behavior consistent with his conduct during previous calls documented under CRN 2506-5852 and 2506-5864.
Despite his demeanor, I continued efforts to de-escalate and resolve his concerns. Due to his insistence and inability to clearly provide [WITNESS #1]’s contact information over the phone, I responded in person to his residence at his request to attempt to obtain the number.
Upon arrival, I observed Mr. McGill sitting on the porch. As I approached, I noticed a brown object in his hand. Based on previous interactions and knowledge that he owns a large revolver stored in a brown leather holster— and his prior statements that “if [he] wanted to kill us, he already would have”—I shined my flashlight in his direction to identify the item. It was determined to be a brown leather football.
Mr. McGill immediately became agitated by the flashlight and began arguing, but I was able to calm him enough to continue speaking. Without being asked, Mr. McGill handed me his unlocked phone, indicating I should locate [WITNESS #1]’s number because he was “bad with technology.” During the interaction, I smelled the odor of an alcoholic beverae that had been present on him and his breath through all prior incidents.
I accessed the call log and located both a missed and an outgoing call to [WITNESS #1] lasting three minutes and one second. I copied the number into my department-issued phone. As I attempted to place a call, Mr. McGill became paranoid and tried to see what I was doing. While it was not an issue for him to view the screen, he began rapidly circling around my right side, closing distance behind me. Given his previous aggressive behavior, I repositioned myself to keep him in front of me. He then began accusing me of going through his phone, at which point I returned his device-though he had not yet asked for it—and showed him my phone, now displaying [WITNESS #1]’s number.
Mr. McGill escalated further, shouting insults related to my personal life, body, and professional conduct. I attempted to de-escalate, but once it became clear he was not responding to reason, I proceeded with the call to [WITNESS #1].
While I was speaking with [WITNESS #1], Mr. McGill continued cursing at both of us. I identified myself to [WITNESS #1] and asked for clarification about the earlier phone exchange. [WITNESS #1] stated he had called Timothy to tell him to stop abusing [REDACTED] and threatening her and the children, and expressed that it was wrong that they were the ones forced to leave the residence. When I asked about any specific threats he may have made, Mr. McGill again began closing distance toward me, shouting that I needed to “fix” the problem and order everyone to stop threatening him.
At this point, I stepped off the porch as Mr. McGill ordered me to leave and continued insulting me. He followed me off the property and tried to listen in on the ongoing call. [WITNESS #1] confirmed that he had told Mr. McGill he would “come over tomorrow and put a stop to the abuse.” I instructed [WITNESS #1] not to involve himself further and advised that if he did feel the need to come to the property, he should first call law enforcement to avoid escalation. Timothy continued to tell me through the encounter that he’d have my a*s and that he was going to take me down adding the point “in court” after some delay.
Mr. McGill remained agitated and continued yelling in front of my patrol vehicle. I attempted to explain to [WITNESS #1] that neither party had been forced to leave and that both had equal standing as Georgia residents. [WITNESS #1] claimed [REDACTED] had told him that law enforcement had made her leave, which contributed to his anger. I advised him that this was inaccurate, and again instructed him not to make threats and to pursue legal remedies if necessary. I then ended the call.
As I attempted to inform Mr. McGill of the outcome of the call he had requested, he abruptly returned to his house and slammed the door. I knocked to provide an update but was interrupted by yelling from inside. Shortly after, dispatch advised that Mr. McGill was again calling 911, this time stating he felt threatened by the deputy on scene and was demanding that Sheriff Jimmy McDuffie personally respond.
Mr. McGill then reopened the door and continued speaking to dispatch through the storm door. Given his escalating behavior, I requested additional units respond to my location. Upon arrival of other deputies, Mr. McGill exited the residence and continued to curse and insult me. At one point, he moved quickly toward the house, reached inside to turn on the porch light, then returned outside. I had him sit down while I briefed the other deputies.
After discussion, I determined not to pursue charges for misuse of 911 at this time, and instead attempted to issue a warning for disorderly conduct and explain the consequences of further such behavior. I advised Mr. McGill not to continue acting in an aggressive and volatile manner.
Mr. McGill replied that he would not quiet down and told us to “copulate with [ourselves],” becoming increasingly agitated and taking an aggressive posture, seemingly attempting to provoke a confrontation. At that point, I moved behind Mr. McGill and placed him under arrest for Disorderly Conduct.
I escorted Mr. McGill to the front of the other deputies’ patrol vehicles and conducted a search incident to arrest. I removed several vape devices from his pockets and placed him in the back seat of the patrol car, adjusting his left handcuff at his request and double-locking both cuffs to ensure proper fit.
I then approached Mr. McGill and asked what he would like us to do with his vape devices, his phone on the porch, and the open front door behind the storm door. I made multiple attempts to assist him in retrieving his property and securing the residence he shared, but Mr. McGill responded only with repeated profane insults and refused to cooperate. Mr. McGill was transported to the Effingham County Jail where he was booked.
[End of Narrative]
