Get notified by email when this case is updated.
1 following this caseName:
Buttice, Madison Bailey
Date of Booking:
02/23/2025
Reason(s) For Booking:
CRUELTY TO CHILDREN-CRIMINAL NEGLIGENCE/CAUSES EXCESSIVE PHYSICAL/MENTAL PAIN – 2ND DEGREE
CRIMINAL TRESPASS – FAMILY VIOLENCE
Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]
On February 23rd 2025 at about 9:48 PM, I responded to [REDACTED BY AGENCY] regarding a domestic dispute. Upon arrival, I met with several adults who were upset with each other. One child and one toddler was also present.
I began by speaking with an 11 year old child identified as [REDACTED BY AGENCY] He explained that his mother had taken a shower and when she was done with the shower, exited the bathroom and started yelling at him and his toddler brother. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] said his mother, identified as Madison Buttice, came into his room and started to choke him. He said he then tried to cover himself with covers on his bed as his mother slapped him repeatedly. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] said his mother grabbed him around the neck for about three seconds with both hands. He said he could still breathe during this time. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] said he was struck three or four times by his mother, but blocked most of the strikes with his arms.
I observed a bloody scratch across [REDACTED BY AGENCY] right eye. A set of finger scratches were observed on the back left side of his neck. Scratches and minor bruising were observed on the front right side of the neck. I also observed a full, welted, left hand print under the right arm along the rib cage. Fingers and the shape of the hand could be easily observed on his torso. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] said he received the mark on his side while his mother was slapping him.
I then spoke with the mother, identified as Madison Buttice. Buttice said all she wanted to do was take a shower in peace. She said [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was supposed to watch his younger brother while she was in the shower, but was playing video games instead. Buttice said she became frustrated when she heard everyone yelling at her as she exited the bathroom after her shower. Out of frustration, she said she grabbed an old glass vase in the bedroom and smashed it down on top of a glass table top which was on top of a vintage wood oriental themed drum end table. The glass vase broke along with the glass table top. The top of the drum was also shredded and torn by the broken glass. The value of the vase was $40. The glass table top was $40. The drum was valued at $164.
Buttice said she slapped [REDACTED BY AGENCY] on the upper buttocks and lower back two times. I asked her how the hand print ended up on his torso under his armpit. Buttice said she must have missed his butt while spanking him. I then asked about the marks on his neck and face. Buttice said she only spanked him and did not remember hitting him above the shoulders. I also asked about her placing her hands around his neck. Buttice again denied choking [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and could not provide a reason he would have fresh scratches and bruising on his neck.
I then spoke with [WITNESS #1] (Grandmother) and [WITNESS #2] (Uncle). Neither of them observed the physical altercation between [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and Buttice. The altercation was heard and recorded (audio only) by [WITNESS #2]. I listened to the first three minutes of the audio recording and recorded such on my body camera. In the audio, Buttice could be heard yelling, cussing and degrading her son.
Based on the physical evidence and testimonial evidence at the scene, Buttice was placed under arrest for Cruelty to Children 2nd degree FVA and Criminal Trespass FVA.
Despite multiple attempts by Dispatch/Service, DFCS could not be reached at the time of this incident. The children, including 2 year old [REDACTED BY AGENCY] were left in the care of [WITNESS #1]. Buttice asked for her children to be taken care of by her friend [REDACTED], but that request was postponed due to not being able to contact DFCS.
Officer Gracia #118 transported Buttice to he Glynn County Detention Center for processing.
I supplied a Victim’s Bill of Rights pamphlet and the incident case number to [WITNESS #1].
Body camera audio and video along with photos of the property damage and physical injuries to [REDACTED BY AGENCY] were uploaded to Evidence.com.
DFCS was faxed a copy of this incident report.
[End of Narrative]
