Get notified by email when this case is updated.
The Georgia Gazette is actively monitoring this case. Check back for the latest updates as more information becomes available.
Name:
Neubert, Matthew David
Date of Booking:
09/16/2026
Reason(s) For Booking:
Duty to Make Immediate Reports of Accidents
Proof of minimum insurance
Registration and License of Motor Vehicles
Obstruction of Officers-(M)
False report of a crime
Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]
On Saturday, September 12th, 2026, at 2207 hours, I, Deputy Thompson, was dispatched to the area of Sandy Run Road and Old Perry Road in reference to an accident.
Upon my arrival to the area, I was flagged down by a passing motorist who advised me of the location of the vehicle. I located the crashed vehicle off the roadway and sitting inside the tree line of [300 BLOCK] Sandy Run Road.
I approached the vehicle, a 2004 gold Honda Accord (AR Plate: [REDACTED]), in an attempt to make contact with the occupant(s), but observed the vehicle had been vacated. I began to search the surrounding woods, ditches, and yards but was unable to locate any of the vehicle’s occupant(s). I ran the vehicle’s tag through dispatch and asked them to run the registered owner’s information.
Dispatch advised the vehicle’s registered owner returned for my suspect, Matthew Neubert, who lived approximately 1.2 miles west of the crash site at [300 BLOCK] Summer Hill Place. I asked dispatch to attempt to make contact with Matthew by phone, but they were unable to get ahold of him. I then attempted to make contact with Matthew by phone but was also unable to get ahold of him.
I then went across the street to [300 BLOCK] Sandy Run Road and made contact with a resident, [WITNESS #1], who advised she heard a sound out in front of her home approximately 15 minutes before my arrival but did not see the crash nor anyone at the crash site. I asked [WITNESS #1] if she had any cameras that could have caught the crash on video. She advised the only camera she had was a doorbell camera, but that it only records when someone rings it.
I then made contact with the residents at [300 BLOCK] and [300 BLOCK] Sandy Run Road. Both advised they did not have cameras that would have recorded the crash, nor did they see or hear anything.
After confirming there were no involved occupants in the area, I began to investigate the scene. I observed skid marks on the fog line east of the crash site and dirt skid marks on the shoulder leading west to the crash site, indicating the vehicle was traveling west. The vehicle appeared to have hit the east side of a large oak tree, where it came to rest.
I gathered photographs of the vehicle and scene while awaiting the on-call tow truck. I then filled out a tow log and performed an inventory search of the vehicle. While performing the inventory, I observed a black ball cap sitting on the front passenger seat and a pink vape sitting inside the center console cup holder.
I made contact with the tow truck driver and advised him to place an investigatory hold on the vehicle. I also ensured the tow company, Kitchens Towing, would notify the Sheriff’s Office if someone attempted to pick it up.
I then returned to my patrol vehicle while Matthew’s car was being loaded onto the tow truck. As I sat in my patrol vehicle, I observed that Matthew had attempted to call me back. I then made contact with him over the phone and advised him of the situation. As I spoke with Matthew, he did not sound surprised at the news and, until I asked him, did not mention the vehicle being stolen.
While working the crash scene, I observed a dark-colored SUV with amber alley lights and a tow company’s markings on the sides pass by the scene multiple times beginning at approximately 2300 hours.
After turning the vehicle over to the tow truck, I went en route to Matthew’s residence.
Upon my arrival, I made contact with Matthew. He first showed me where he parked the vehicle, which was on the west side of the house. He then stated that he had been looking through his security camera footage in an attempt to locate possible footage of what he claimed to be a theft. I observed him scrolling through the camera footage but did not click on any highlighted incidents. He advised he would go get his aunt, who had “the main login” to the security account and that she would have a “better view” of the footage.
I then gathered photographs of the vehicle’s parking spot. As I photographed the scene, I observed tire marks leading from the vehicle’s parking spot to the driveway, within view of the security camera.
Matthew then provided me with his driver’s license so that I could confirm his identity. I ran his information through dispatch. As I did, he abruptly sat down in the driveway.
I asked Matthew where he kept the keys to his vehicle. He advised he kept them inside of the car.
He then advised that the vehicle was not drivable, citing electrical issues with the ignition. He then stated that he had not driven the vehicle in approximately 2-3 months. He then advised that the issue was due to a “parasitic draw” and that he would have to charge the battery and utilize a kill switch, but even with these fixes, it would give him issues. He then stated that he “did not even know it (his vehicle) was drivable.”
He then advised that he had not registered the vehicle nor obtained insurance for it and did not plan to do so until it was “drivable completely.” He also stated the vehicle had not given him a “reason to trust it thus far.”
While I spoke with Matthew, I noticed he was holding a pink vape identical to the one I located inside the cup holder of his vehicle.
I then asked him who else lived inside the home with him. He advised his aunt, [WITNESS #2], also lived in the home. I asked him to spell [WITNESS #2]’s last name for me. He spelled it “[WITNESS #2]” I then asked him to spell her first name. He spelled it “[WITNESS #2]”
I then asked Matthew if I could speak with [WITNESS #2]. He advised he, in fact, did not go inside to wake her up as he earlier stated he was doing and stated he had been inside continuing to review the security footage.
Matthew went back inside then returned with [WITNESS #2] and her husband, [WITNESS #3]. I advised them both of the situation and asked if either of them had driven the vehicle. Matthew interjected and stated they had not. [WITNESS #2] and [WITNESS #3] both advised the last time they saw the vehicle was at approximately 1600-1700 hours on the day of this incident.
[WITNESS #2] showed me the security camera footage. I observed the following:
At approximately 2150 hours, the camera caught Matthew walking from the front of the house around the side of the house where the vehicle was parked. While he walked past the camera, he was wearing a ball cap. I was unable to make out the color of the ball cap, but it appeared to be lighter in color. Then, at approximately 2152 hours, the camera captured the vehicle pulling out from the side yard into the driveway, out into the street, and then driving away. I could not make out a good description of the driver, but he did appear to be wearing a lighter-colored ball cap.
The camera did not catch Matthew walking back around to the front of the house. Matthew advised that he was “just taking” and did not finish his statement of what he was doing. I observed the property during daylight hours on Google Earth Street View. I did not view any side doors to the residence but did observe that there was a fence and possibly a gate that led to the backyard.
The next clip showed Matthew exit his buddy “[WITNESS #4]’s” vehicle after pulling into the driveway at 2244 hours.
Then, at approximately 2253 hours, his buddy “[WITNESS #4]” pulled up in front of Matthew’s house in his dark-colored, marked roadside-assistance vehicle that had amber alley lights. [WITNESS #4] was also wearing his reflective jacket. Matthew then stated that he and [WITNESS #4] went to Steak ‘n Shake and then drove around.
I then advised Matthew that [WITNESS #4]’s vehicle had passed the crash scene multiple times while I was out there. I asked Matthew if he recalled seeing myself or my patrol vehicle, which was blocking the entire eastbound lane and had his vehicle illuminated with my takedown lights. Matthew advised he did not recall. He then further advised that while riding with [WITNESS #4], they never drove on Sandy Run Road during their trip to Steak ‘n Shake.
I then asked Matthew to describe [WITNESS #4]’s vehicle. He advised he believed it was some type of Chevrolet that had markings on the side and amber lights on it. He advised [WITNESS #4] uses it for roadside recoveries.
I then addressed my suspicions and the inconsistencies with Matthew while advising him that he was voluntarily speaking with me and that he was not detained. He then became defensive and stated he was a victim of an auto theft and felt as if he was being accused of driving the vehicle. I advised him that I was not accusing him and was just trying to gather all the facts of the case.
I provided Matthew with the case number and information on how to obtain a copy of this report.
I found the following inconsistencies through my investigation:
Matthew walked in the direction of his vehicle less than two minutes before the vehicle drove off. Per his own statements, the vehicle would have had to be worked on for some time before being started. Matthew advised that as he walked around to the side of the house, he did not observe any suspicious people in the area.
[WITNESS #4]’s vehicle passed the scene multiple times, drawing my attention, during the same time frame Matthew was supposed to be riding around with him. Matthew stated he did not notice the crash site or his vehicle in the ditch.
The vehicle was driven west toward Matthew’s house. I believe this is notable, as driving a vehicle toward the scene from which you just stole it is odd.
Based on the way Matthew spoke about [WITNESS #4] and [WITNESS #4], I believe he was speaking of the same person. I asked Matthew why [WITNESS #4] would drop him off in one vehicle and then, approximately an hour later, return and pick him up in a different vehicle. He began to stumble over his words and then gave an unclear answer.
Additionally, while speaking with Matthew, I observed slightly slurred speech, droopy eyes, odd inconsistent, responses and a strong odor of cologne.
The next day, 09/13/2026, I made contact with the first 911 caller of the crash, [WITNESS #5]. She advised she was only on scene for a moment but provided me with some context to the incident.
She observed a Hispanic man on a moped and the driver of the vehicle standing on scene. After confirming both parties were okay, she was told by the driver that, as he came around the corner, he swerved to miss the moped, causing him to crash.
[WITNESS #5] described the driver as a white male in his late twenties or thirties. He had a beard and mustache, with all his hair being very dark. The driver was wearing baggy, dark, possibly gray-colored pants and a dark-colored shirt. She did advise there was little light on scene and that she was not confident in the exact colors of the driver’s clothing. She also advised that she was a linguist and noticed he spoke clear English and did not have a Southern accent. She added that it may have been a “Yank” accent, but if it was, it was not strong.
Matthew did have dark hair with a beard and mustache on the day of the crash. While speaking with Matthew, I noticed he had a subtle Northern accent. On the security footage from Matthew’s house, I observed he was wearing a lighter-colored shirt and dark pants. Additionally, according to Matthew’s driver’s license, he is five foot-eight inches tall. He is also quite skinny.
Based on the facts of this case, I will be seeking the following warrants on Matthew;
- O.C.G.A 16-10-24 – Obstructing or hindering law enforcement officers
- O.C.G.A 40-6-273. Duty to report accident resulting property damage
- O.C.G.A 16-10-26. False report of a crime
- O.C.G.A 40-6-10. Insurance requirements for operation of motor vehicles
- O.C.G.A 40-2-29 Registration required
[End of Narrative]
All information is sourced directly from the official, public court database. Case history is organized and curated by The Georgia Gazette staff. The “What this means:” explanations are written by AI and reviewed by our staff before publishing.
Court records are subject to change at the court’s discretion. The Georgia Gazette is not responsible for errors or omissions. Nothing here is legal advice. All individuals are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law.
Case History:
11/9/26
ACCUSATION FILED — 5 COUNTS AGAINST MATTHEW DAVID NEUBERT
What this means: Prosecutors in the Houston County State Court filed a formal accusation — a charging document — against Matthew David Neubert on November 9, 2026, under case number 2026CR0118534. An accusation is how misdemeanor-level charges are formally brought in Georgia’s State Court, without requiring a grand jury. Matthew David Neubert is accused of five misdemeanor offenses stemming from incidents on September 12 and 16, 2026, in Houston County.
Count 1 — Obstruction of an Officer (O.C.G.A. 16-10-24(a)): Matthew David Neubert is accused of knowingly and willfully obstructing Deputy Deven Thompson of the Houston County Sheriff’s Office on or about September 16, 2026, by allegedly providing false statements during the investigation of an unreported automobile accident.
Count 2 — False Report of a Crime (O.C.G.A. 16-10-26): The defendant is accused of willfully and knowingly giving a false report of a crime — specifically, a theft by taking — to Deputy Deven Thompson on or about September 12, 2026.
Count 3 — Failure to Report Accident (O.C.G.A. 40-6-273): Matthew David Neubert is accused of being the driver of a vehicle involved in an accident on or about September 12, 2026, that caused property damage of $500 or more, and allegedly failing to notify the local police department or the Houston County Sheriff’s Office by the quickest available means.
Count 4 — Operating a Vehicle Without Insurance (O.C.G.A. 40-6-10(b)): The defendant is accused of knowingly operating a 2004 Honda Accord on Sandy Run Road on or about September 12, 2026, without having effective insurance on the vehicle.
Count 5 — Expired Tag (O.C.G.A. 40-2-8): Matthew David Neubert is accused of operating a motor vehicle on Sandy Run Road on or about September 12, 2026, without having the required revalidation decal affixed to the license plate.
11/9/26
PROSECUTOR ASSIGNED
What this means: Andrew W. Jenkins, Assistant Solicitor-General for Houston County, was assigned as the prosecuting attorney on Matthew David Neubert’s case, number 2026CR0118534, in Houston County State Court.
11/12/26
ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED FOR 11/12/26
What this means: An arraignment was scheduled for Matthew David Neubert on November 12, 2026, at 8:00 AM in Houston County State Court. An arraignment is the court appearance where a defendant is formally informed of the charges against them and enters an initial plea of guilty, not guilty, or nolo contendere.
11/17/26
NOT GUILTY PLEA ENTERED — JURY TRIAL REQUESTED
What this means: Matthew David Neubert entered a not guilty plea in Houston County State Court on November 17, 2026, in case number 2026CR0118534. The defendant also requested a jury trial, meaning the case will be decided by a panel of jurors rather than by the judge alone. A public defender has been appointed to represent him.
6/28/27
CALENDAR CALL SCHEDULED FOR 6/28/27
What this means: A calendar call has been scheduled for Matthew David Neubert’s case on June 28, 2027, at 1:30 PM in Houston County State Court. A calendar call is a routine court date where the judge checks the status of pending cases and confirms whether they are ready to proceed to trial.
8/16/27
JURY TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 8/16/27
What this means: A jury trial has been scheduled for Matthew David Neubert on August 16, 2027, at 1:30 PM in Houston County State Court, case number 2026CR0118534. At trial, the State will need to prove each of the five misdemeanor counts beyond a reasonable doubt. Matthew David Neubert is presumed innocent unless and until the State meets that burden.
