Get notified by email when this case is updated.
Name:
Erwin, Tony Curtis
Date of Booking:
03/16/2022
Reason(s) For Booking:
Indictment or Accusation
Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]
On 11/30/2021 I was contacted by Det. HOLMES with Whitfield County Sheriff’s Office and [WITNESS #1], Executive Director of the GREENHOUSE SAC/CAC facility. Both individuals informed me of a forensic interview conducted with 10-year-old [REDACTED BY AGENCY]. DET. HOLMES advised that a program called “LAUREN’s KIDS” was conducted at the school [REDACTED BY AGENCY] attends (VARNELL elementary). This program is in place to educate students regarding body safety. [WITNESS #2] (a counselor at VARNELL elementary) reported that she observed [REDACTED BY AGENCY] to be visibly upset and crying after the program was taught. [WITNESS #2] stated that she spoke with [REDACTED BY AGENCY] asking if there was something wrong. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] did reply advising something was wrong, but she could not speak about it or her GRANDFATHER, TONY would “spank her”. [WITNESS #2] then asked if TONY had done something to make her uncomfortable, and if he had touched her private area. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] replied, “yes, he did”.
[REDACTED BY AGENCY] biological father, [REDACTED] did bring [REDACTED BY AGENCY] to the GREENHOUSE in DALTON, GA. [WITNESS #1] did conduct a forensic interview with [REDACTED BY AGENCY]. [WITNESS #1] also completed a forensic interview summary of the disclosures made during the interview. The following information was disclosed:
[REDACTED BY AGENCY] states that she had told Ms. [WITNESS #2] that someone “touched her inappropriately”. [WITNESS #1] asked her to tell her about that, and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] paused without speaking. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] then states that it made her feel “uncomfortable”. She states that [WITNESS #2] is a guidance teacher. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] then states that her “grandpa told her if she told anyone she would get a spanking”. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] states her grandfather is her dad’s dad. She states that sometimes she goes to visit them.
She describes one incident to have occurred in the living room, on the couch, with her grandpa inside her grandpa’s residence. She describes the couch as “chairs put together”. She stated that he “scooted close to me and he touched me”. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] states that he used his “hands” to touch her “bad spot”. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] then points to her groin area to indicate the location of her bad spot on her body. She stated that she also calls that area her “hoohah”. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] states that his hand touched her “hoohah” on the outside of her clothing. She stated that his hand just stayed there “still”. She stated that she was wearing leggings and a shirt. She stated he stopped when she got up and walked away to go to her room. She stated that it occurred last school year while it was warm outside and that she was nine years old. However, she states this happened a few times.
[REDACTED BY AGENCY] states he also pinches her “upper part” indicating her breast area. She states that it has been happening for about a year. She then describes a specific time of eating steak in the kitchen with her “Grandpa”. She stated during this incident he pinched her “one time” on her “upper area” and it felt “weird”.
[REDACTED BY AGENCY] then describes an incident when her “Grandpa” showed her his “hoohah”. She states he took her out to his garage and that she looked away to see all the stuff in the garage. She states when she looked back at him “it was out” and he told her to “touch it” but she walked away. She states that inside the “small room in the garage” were ropes, motorcycles, and helmets. She stated that her “grandpa” had closed the door on the small room of the garage. She stated that “it” referred to his “hoohah”. She stated she was 8 and ½ because it was close to her birthday in June. When asked what his “hoohah” looked like she stated, “a hotdog”. She stated he was his was holding “it” with two hands and his hands were not moving. She stated he “kept saying touch it” and she kept telling him “No”.
[REDACTED BY AGENCY] states on the day he taught her about something that she couldn’t have been taught, he told her that if she tells anyone, he will whoop her”. She stated that he told her “It” was called S.E.X. and that it when “a guy puts his hoohah in the girls”. She stated that she was eight years old and inside her room at “grandpa’s” house. She stated that this occurred in the afternoon. She stated she was sitting on her bed listening to music on her “Alexia”. She stated that her “grandpa” came in the room and set down on her bed and told her “He wanted to teach it to her”. She stated that a few months ago, he told her that “she had been taught enough but he won’t stop”. When asked what she meant by “he won’t stop”, she states that “he keeps doing it but he is not teaching me”. She states that when she says, “doing it” she means “he keeps touching me”. She states his hand has not gone beneath her clothing.
Lastly, she states that he has not spanked her before, but she has seen him get mad and get into “argues” with her “grandma”. She states that “grandma” will then come downstairs and sleep with her, and “grandpa” will get really angry and “talk to himself”.
Throughout the interview [REDACTED BY AGENCY] remains slouched over with her hands and her lap speaking very softly.
On 12/02/2021 I spoke with TONY ERWIN at his residence. I advised TONY that I was at his house and anytime he wished for me to leave I would leave. I advised I do not have an arrest warrant and he did not have to speak with me. I advised that statements were made by [REDACTED BY AGENCY] against him and I am speaking with him to investigate those statements referring to criminal activity. I advised that he could speak with an attorney instead of speaking with me and if he could not afford an attorney, an attorney could be appointed to him at the government’s expense. I then asked if he would be willing to speak with me. He stated he understood and that he would speak with me. Due to explanation of my presence, the purpose of my questions and his willingness to speak at his own residence with the ability to go back inside or ask me to leave, it is believed that all statements were made voluntarily.
TONY states that “they” had been trying to correct bad behavior learned from her mother as soon as she came to their residence. He then states “I wonder why this is coming up now because I thought she was ok”. I advised that a disclosure derived from [REDACTED BY AGENCY] after a program at the school that teaches about body safety. TONY states that “we have been teaching her about the importance of the word, NO”. He states that her mother had been teaching her the “butt bump” and that she had been dancing inappropriately in front of “him”. TONY stated for about “four years” he had been turning her away from “that style of life”. He states that he even told his wife “I taught her enough, I am done teaching her”. TONY stated that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] had been through “sexual stuff” with her mother and her mother’s boyfriends. She stated when they got here her and her little sister were a “mess”. He stated that they wore no panties, doing all kinds of “sexual intendos”, and some “rubbing touching feely stuff”. He stated that for the past four years they tried to correct this behavior.
I asked if he and his wife had sat down with [REDACTED BY AGENCY] together to correct her or had he ever had the “sex talk” with [REDACTED BY AGENCY] one on one. He states yes. TONY states this new information has to be from the hurt she had experienced in the past. He also expressed concern about Mother’s current boyfriend [REDACTED]. I asked if she ever disclosed anything happening with someone else such as [REDACTED] or anyone else. He stated, no, she wouldn’t say, “[REDACTED BY AGENCY] keeps a lot inside and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] hides a lot”. TONY stated he has asked direct questions such as “have they touched you inappropriately or have they done things while she was trying to sleep”.
I asked what were normal activities with him and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] when she is there. He states she usually stays with his wife. He states that when she gets out of school and is coming to the residence, she will go to his wife’s salon. I asked if he ever keeps [REDACTED BY AGENCY] by himself and he states “never”. He also stated he is “never alone with her” despite earlier stating he has had one on one talks concerning “sex”. He stated that they made it a point for him not to watch the children alone, so it didn’t look “weird”.
I then asked when they talk to [REDACTED BY AGENCY], about private areas of the body, what words they would use to describe the v*gina. He stated that he lets his wife talk about that and that he would just say privates. TONY states that maybe we should have called “ya ‘ll” when they first showed up. He states he doesn’t know what has happened to her because when she showed up here “they were riskay”. He stated that the behavior he was referring to was the dances they would do, and music and videos they would listen to. I then asked if he ever caught [REDACTED BY AGENCY] or her younger sister doing or watching something overtly sexually such as watching pornography, and he stated “no”.
I then read the disclosures listed on the forensic interview summary. When I read the disclosure concerning the physical contact with her v*gina or “hoohah” above clothing and pinching her breast or “upper area”. Tony states that they would “wrestle pinch and play rough because she is a tom boy”. I then read the disclosure referring to the exposure of TONY’s privates to [REDACTED BY AGENCY]. TONY states “I know what that was”. He states he was peeing outside of the building and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] walked up. He states she is really quiet and you don’t hear her walking up and “I guess she caught me”. I then asked if she did see his privates and he says, “I guess, I don’t know”.
I advised that when I told him the disclosure, he seemed certain she saw him peeing”, he then replies, “that was the only time she seen it”. I then asked him to clarify did she see it or did she not see it. He then states I don’t know, all I know is I was peeing, and she saw me. I asked if he was facing her or facing away from her, he stated he was standing sideways. I then asked how she reacted and how he reacted when she came out there. He stated that she acted like nothing was going on. I asked if she stayed out there or walked away. He stated she stayed out there and talked to me and then left. I asked if at any point did you ask her to look away or turn around, and he stated that he didn’t even know she was out there despite him stating he was standing sideways in perspective to where [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was standing. I then advised that he had stated she was talking to him, he then stated she talked to him after he finished and didn’t know she was out there while he was peeing. He also stated the same day he went to tell [WITNESS #3] about [REDACTED BY AGENCY] walking out and catching him peeing. TONY stated that the building he was peeing beside was the building that contained a motorcycle (a building with a garage roll up door and one side door). I did ask about the outbuilding previously in the interview and if [REDACTED BY AGENCY] ever goes into the building. TONY stated she has been in there one time when she first got here to see the motorcycle and she hasn’t been back in because she is scared to go in the buildings. I asked why she was scared, and he stated because there are “big snakes in the buildings”.
I then began to read another portion of the FIS in which [REDACTED BY AGENCY] states that her GRANDPA would come in her room, and TONY interrupted to say “when she first came here she was PROMISCUOUS”. He then asked if I knew what that word means. TONY then defines by saying she was “overly to much about sex”. He states she was fed the Youtube, and she thinks that is how she is supposed to be. I then advised that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] states when GRANDPA came in her room he would want to teach her about sex. I asked if he had ever had the “sex talk”. He stated that he has had the “sex talk” a lot with her. He stated the sex talk would include what is inappropriate and what not to do. He also states that he talked to her about where babies come from because that was the biggest problem. He states the problem about teaching against it is you have to teach about it. TONY asks if I had spoken to [WITNESS #3] and [REDACTED] and what they thought. I advised that I wanted to speak with him because he is who she has disclosed against. He then states “if anything ever happen like that it is when she has clothes on”, and “it was PROBABLY just wrestling or playing”
I then advised that the first thing she describes a hand was placed over clothing on “that area” indicating the v*gina. He states she just “felt uncomfortable at times”. I then asked directly if there was a time where his hand was on that area”. He then pauses and says “no”, “I mean no”. He then states that she is very “comfortable with him”, and they would wrestle, and maybe his hand would be left on her leg too long. I then stated she did not describe her leg. I advised she describes her “hoohah”. Then despite his pause previously regarding the same addressment, he quickly states “I’ve never touched that area”. I then asked despite all of the men she has had in her life through mother’s boyfriends, boys at school, and her father; what would make her accuse him. He states it is because he is around her more. TONY states that “he had went as far as he could go about teaching her about sex and all of that”. He stated he is the only one that could do it because GRANDMA couldn’t do it and DAD couldn’t do it.
He stated “there are certain things about sex that she wouldn’t open up to talk to nobody accept PAPAW, because he has been close to her since he knew her”. I asked if she would come to him to talk or if he would have to go to her. He stated that she would come home talking about boys in school that would step on her toes. He state he would tell her “you know that’s what it is for” and they would talk then. I asked if she had suggested that these boys at school were interested in sex. He stated “without being a nun, SHE HATES SEX”, and “even if I put my hand on her leg it would bother her”, despite him talking about wrestling with her. He states that “they had been trying to teach her against that but maybe we went to far”. He then states they had been teaching her about abstinence. He also makes a statement that he would go into her room to talk about that and the door would be open and [WITNESS #3] would be in the kitchen.
I later ask the layout of the home and he states [REDACTED BY AGENCY]’s room and the living room is downstairs and their bed room is upstairs. I asked if he and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] hang out or watch movies, would it be in her room or his room or a common area. He then states “he never goes in her room except to say goodnight despite previously stating that he would talk about abstinence in her room with the door open.
Towards the end of the interview TONY states “here lately I have been giving her a body hug to get close to her and so she is not scared of him”. I asked why she would be scared of him and he states because he wants respect and when she gets in trouble he would tell her he would whoop her. He then states she hasn’t been getting in trouble and he hasn’t whipped her. This contradicts the fact that the entire interview he has stated that she is so comfortable with him and they have such a good relationship and then states she has a reason to be scared of him.
On 12/05/2021 I spoke with [WITNESS #3] at the Murray County Sheriff’s Office. [WITNESS #3] became very emotional multiple times regarding the details of [REDACTED BY AGENCY]s disclosures. [WITNESS #3] does state that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] had problems not wearing panties because she didn’t like the way they felt. She stated that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] never had that problem. [WITNESS #3] stated that she never observed sexual behaviors. She stated that the only thing she has seen to be considered inappropriate was a time she had to correct the way she dance placing her butt against TONY, and times that she would be giving the girls a bath she had to get on to them about opening the bathroom door while TONY was in the other room. However she states her addressment was to tell them not to do that. She gave no description of a time she had to have a conversation about sex with the children. She doesn’t recall TONY telling her about either of the girls walking up on him peeing outside.
[WITNESS #3] does describe times that there were times TONY would go in [REDACTED BY AGENCY] room to play with her with the door open. [WITNESS #3] also states that less than five times, TONY did have to watch or baby sit the girls by himself. [WITNESS #3] does state that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] father, [WITNESS #4] did have [REDACTED BY AGENCY] 90 percent of the time. I then asked about her sexual relationship with TONY. She does say that years prior he would become frustrated because she was tired all the time from work. She states now he understands that she is tired. At the end of the interview [WITNESS #3] does advised that she would not call [REDACTED BY AGENCY] a liar regarding the statements made.
On the same date I spoke to [WITNESS #5] (BMO to [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and [REDACTED BY AGENCY]) by telephone. [WITNESS #5] does advise that TONY would buy [REDACTED BY AGENCY] things like a Christian promise ring, and special stuffed animals. She also advises that despite TONY stating [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was scared to go in the garage due to snakes, [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was not scared of snakes and would often handle or pick up snakes while living in LOUIS ANNA.
On 12/08/2021 a forensic interview was conducted with [REDACTED BY AGENCY] is an eight-year-old stepsister of [REDACTED BY AGENCY] has been present at the same home of TONY, [REDACTED] (TONY’S wife) and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] stated that she did not live at the residence with TONY, [WITNESS #3] and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] She states that she goes over to the residence in question ([REDACTED BY AGENCY], GA) is when her dad is working or when she wants to see [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was unable to recall the name of grandfather. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was able t identify the private areas of the body. [REDACTED BY AGENCY] did not make disclosures of any activity consistent with criminal activity concerning the private areas of the body.
Following the interview with [REDACTED BY AGENCY] I spoke with [REDACTED BY AGENCY] father [WITNESS #4]. [WITNESS #4] stated that approximately five years prior while [WITNESS #5] (mother of [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and [REDACTED BY AGENCY]) was in GA, [WITNESS #4] got visitation with his daughter. [WITNESS #4] stated that due to [REDACTED] being stationed in JAPAN while in the military, [WITNESS #4] got both [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and [WITNESS #4] during his visitations. [WITNESS #4] stated while caring for both children, he did not observe or have to correct sexual or sexually reactive behavior. [WITNESS #4] also describes [REDACTED BY AGENCY] behavior at the time to be very outgoing, despite her current behavior appearing to be more “shut down” or introvert.
[End of Narrative]
