Get notified by email when this case is updated.
Name:
Smith, Andrew Tyler
Date of Booking:
03/25/2025
Reason(s) For Booking:
Aggravated Assault, Other Weapon
Probation Violation, Felony
Cruelty To Child, Excess Physical / Mental Pain, 1st
Cruelty To Child, Allow To Witness Fel/ Bat/ Fv, 3rd
Cruelty To Child, Allow To Witness Fel/ Bat/ Fv, 3rd
Battery
Cruelty To Child, Allow To Witness Fel/ Bat/ Fv, 3rd
Criminal Damage To Property, Private, 2nd Degree
Officer’s Narrative:
[Please note: The following is a direct transcription from the official initial incident report. The Georgia Gazette does not fix any spelling or grammatical errors that may exist. Any changes or redactions made by our staff are placed inside brackets. Some errors may exist. All subjects are innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. The topics discussed may be sensitive to some readers. Discretion is advised.]
On 03/25/25, I was dispatched to [1800 BLOCK] Shadow Ln in reference to a 911 hang up call with female’s screaming in the background. Dispatch that a female was screaming, “I have children” and that a second female confirmed the address before disconnecting. Dispatch did not have a response after trying to call back.
Once on scene, myself and Ofc Akins could hear a woman screaming from an upstairs room as we were approaching the building. I then moved closer to [1800 BLOCK] Shadow Ln Apt [REDACTED]’s door and was able to hear a female, later identified as [VICTIM #1], screaming and crying through the door. I also heard a male, later identified as Andrew Smith, yelling as well. [VICTIM #1] sounded as though she was pleading with Andrew. Andrew was yelling at [VICTIM #1] and telling her to “hurry up and find it” and “I’ve got to fu*king go” because the police were coming. I then heard Andrew begin to count down from 10 and continue to scream yell at [VICTIM #1] as she continued to cry and plead.
It was at this time, that I knocked loudly on the door announced that I was police and that someone needed to open the door immediately. The room went silent and no one responded to me. I commanded again for someone to open the door. Still, no one answered. Given the comments made by Andrew and the sounds of [VICTIM #1] in distress, I decided to enter the residence to ensure the safety of [VICTIM #1] and the children inside. I tried the door handle but the door was locked. I then began to kick the door in an attempt to gain entry. After several kicks, I could hear someone begin to unlock the door. I then drew my firearm from its holster and held it at a Sul position (muzzle to the ground). [VICTIM #1] then opened the door.
I observed that [VICTIM #1] was visibly injured around her mouth and that she was bleeding from the mouth. [VICTIM #1] was completely nude and was crying and begging for us to help her and her children. She stated that he had broken everything and “beaten the sh*t out of me”. [VICTIM #1] did not wish to step outside in her current state. Ofc Akins provided her with his jacket and we then made entry to the residence. I called out into the residence and advised that anyone in the residence should make themselves known. A young boy, later identified as [REDACTED BY AGENCY] (7), ran out of the hallway and began to cry. I then instructed him to come to me but he sat in the hallway and continued to cry. [VICTIM #1] then retrieved him and brought him to us. From my position just inside the door, I could see that nearly every item in the living room had been flipped over or broken. There was a TV that had been shattered into several pieces and furniture flipped upside down. There was debris covering the floor of the living area in the house.
It was at this time that several other officers arrived on scene to assist. With assistance from the other officers, the residence was cleared and two more children were located, [REDACTED BY AGENCY] (1) and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] (>1). Andrew was not located in the residence. It was discovered that there was a balcony on the residence that lead to the ground and it is believed that Andrew fled using this exit while officers were making entry.
I then spoke with [VICTIM #1]. She advised that she and Andrew were married and that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] were their children. She stated that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] was her child from another father. She stated that she had invited a friend, later identified as [VICTIM #2], over to hang out. She stated that she, [VICTIM #2], and Andrew all began to drink together. She stated that they all agreed that they wished to have intercourse with one another. She stated that they began to have intercourse but stopped briefly. She stated that Andrew became very angered and began to shout and cuss at [VICTIM #2] and her. She stated that Andrew told [VICTIM #2] to get out of his house and told [VICTIM #1] that “they were done.” She stated that [VICTIM #2] left the room and returned a short time later. She stated that when [VICTIM #2] walked into the room, Andrew grabbed [VICTIM #2] by the head and then slammed her into the wall near the frame of the door to the bedroom. She stated that Andrew then dragged [VICTIM #2] out of the room and down the hallway. She stated that she then hid under the covers of the bed.
She stated that Andrew entered the room a short time later and began to hit her while she was under the covers. She stated that it felt like Andrew was hitting her with closed fists. She stated that he then pulled the blanket off of her and placed his hands around her throat. He stated that he then began to strangle her. [VICTIM #1] stated that Andrew was gripping her neck so hard that she could feel “popping” in her neck and she could not breath. She stated that she thought that Andrew was going to kill her. She stated that Andrew then stuck one of his hands deep into her mouth and was clawing at the back of her mouth. She stated that it felt like her was trying to rip her tongue out. She stated that Andrew then let her go and began to destroy various items around the house. She stated that he continued to destroy things while ordering her to find his vape. She stated that she was searching for his vape and he continued to count down from different numbers while yelling at her. She stated that she then heard officers at the door and fled down the hall to find her children. She stated that she then came back to the front door and unlocked it to let us in. [VICTIM #1] stated that, during the incident, Andrew had also gone up to the bassinet containing [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and shook the bassinet violently with the child still inside. She stated that [REDACTED BY AGENCY] and [REDACTED BY AGENCY] were in the next room over while the incident took place. [VICTIM #1] stated that she had spoken to [VICTIM #2] again and had her returning to the scene to be interviewed.
It was during this time, Lt Woods advised over the radio, “I have him on the back porch. I then quickly moved to the back porch/ balcony area and observed Lt Woods standing and point his taser at Andrew who was facing away from officers with his hands behind his back. I then moved in and secured Andrew and handcuffs. I then took Andrew out of the residence and to the front of Ofc Akins patrol car. Ofc Akins then searched Andrew incident to arrest and secured Andrew in the back seat of his patrol car.
I then returned to the scene where Ofc Aldava was speaking with [VICTIM #1].
[VICTIM #2] had returned to the scene and I then spoke with her. She stated that they were all hanging out and having drinks when they decided to all have intercourse. She stated that Andrew began to do something different in the bedroom and [VICTIM #1] and she paused for a moment. She stated that Andrew then became angered with the two of them and ordered for her to leave the house. [VICTIM #2] stated that she walked to the living room and got her hoodie. She stated that she then walked back to the bedroom to tell [VICTIM #1] that she was leaving. She stated that Andrew grabbed her with a hand on each side of her head and pushed her into a wall near the door frame of the bedroom. She stated that he continued to drag her down the hallway and into the living area before he let her go. She stated that she then called 911 and was speaking with a dispatcher when [VICTIM #1] asked her not to. She stated that she then hung up the phone and left the residence.
[VICTIM #1] had visible injuries to her mouth, face, and neck. Photos of these injuries were taken. [VICTIM #2] had a small scratch on her left arm, a red mark at the base of her hairline on the back of her neck, and an red abrasion on the left side of her neck. The photos of the injuries for the two females have been attached to the report. Andrew had a scratch mark on the left side of his face. He also had a cut and a small amount of blood on the middle finger of his right hand. There were also many photos taken of the crime scene depicting broken items in the home, damaged walls, blood stains on the bed, and blood smears on the walls in the bedroom and hallway.
Ofc Akins transported Andrew to the WCSO jail. I then relocated there later. Once on scene at the jail, I secured my firearm in the lock box inside my patrol car. I then charged Andrew with aggravated assault (FV), cruelty to children in the 1st degree (FV), cruelty to children in the 3rd degree (X3), damage to property in the 2nd degree, and battery on warrantless arrest #70101.
Victim’s rights forms were provided and explained to [VICTIM #1] and [VICTIM #2].
[End of Narrative]
